Christina simpson harvard graduate school of education may 2016. Standardized testing is again under scrutiny following the news that the house of delegates in maryland approved a legislation that will put a limit to the test to only two percent classroom time each year, which is. It measures only a small portion of what makes education meaningful. Standardized testing, the bane of many high school students existence. Standardized tests discriminate against minority and lower. A primer highlights a test is an objective and standardized method for estimating behavior, based on a sample of that behavior. The debate over standardized testing can be heated. Effects of standardized testing on students wellbeing christina. Through the issuance of standardized tests, institutions can easily sort and compartmentalize individuals based on test questions that serve as a measuring stick of a students academic capacity. Many teachers commented on how standardized testing impacts their regular schedules and curriculum.
What are the pros and cons of potentially using nwea map growth as a. To come up with a wise opinion on this matter, let us take a look at the pros and cons of standardized testing. This is mostly because these scores become public record, and teachers and schools that dont perform up to par can come under intense examination. A hotly debated topic, we look at some of the pros and cons of these tests, and ask your opinion on the issue. Standardized tests are designed to evaluate and then compare the aptitudes or competencies of a diverse population of individuals e.
The gathering resistance to standardized tests by the. Testing more, teaching less is part of delivering on our commitment to provide guidelines, studies and other helpful information to our members and the broader public about the nature, amount and costs of student assessments. Pros and cons use of standardized tests page 2 cheating by teachers and administrators on standardized tests is rare, and not a reason to stop testing americas children. American and japanese views and visions of education, and they point to quite different directions and paths of reform in the two nations. Us students slipped from being ranked 18th in the world in math in 2000 to 40th in 2015, and from 14th to 25th in science and from 15th to 24th in reading. The impression behindhand statewide or national testing is mostly that all students are learning the similar stuffs at the same period so every student are on the. Others believe that standardized testing provides skewed, inaccurate results. When a standardized test is administrated, is it done so according to certain rules and specifications so that testing conditions are the same for all test takers. Christina simpson harvard graduate school of education may. Pros and cons of standardized testing essay 1919 words. Standardized testing grew in acceptance and popularity within the education. The effect of standardized testing on historical literacy and. Jun 28, 2016 standardized testing is typically defined as the nationwide testing that takes place in order to rank students according to the same standard. It has become part of the education system in many countries.
Methods of teaching conform to the multiplechoice format. Bracey, phd and education researcher, there are certain qualities that standardized tests cannot measure, such as critical thinking, creativity, motivation, resilience, curiosity, persistence, reliability, endurance, empathy, enthusiasm, selfdiscipline. Pros and cons of standardized testing amazon web services. It is a reliable and objective measure of student achievement. Standardized testing and reporting star programs no. Pros and cons use of standardized tests page 4 who studies have shown adapt more easily to the gamelike point scoring of multiplechoice questions. It is a terrible waste of precious time that could be utilized to continue with rich andengaginglessons. Standardized testing and its side effects has been part of the u. The downside of standardized testing partnership for the public. Its important to cut through the debate and identify exactly what these. Some say that standardized testing is the best way to accurately evaluate students.
Aug 26, 2017 standardized testing, the bane of many high school students existence. A standardized testis one that uses uniform procedures for administration and scoring in order to assure that. Pdf in light of the constantly expanding use of standardized tests sts not only in. For years, children of all ages have been required to take standardized tests in order to assess their capabilities and theoretically prepare them for further education. Robert schaeffer quotes standardized tests have historically been used as measures of how students are compared with one another or how. The standardized testing environment can be very stressful for some students, especially since it is timed. Standardized testing is again under scrutiny following the news that the house of delegates in maryland approved a legislation that will put a limit to the test to only two percent classroom time each year, which is equivalent to 20 hours annually. Brown and others published the benefits of regular standardized assessment in childhood education.
The disadvantages of standardized testing essay 1487. Others say such a onesizefitsall approach to assessing academic achievement can be inflexible or even biased. In the modern educational environment, standardized testing is used to evaluate students and their teachers with how well they are performing. It will argue that standardized testing contributes to student. The cons of standardized testing may 29, 2014 kimberly lyon 2 comments when taking a further look at standardized testing, it is easy to see why it is an effective strategy used throughout different educational levels. Racial justice and standardized educational testing. A standardized testis one that uses uniform procedures for administration and scoring in order to assure that results from different people are comparable. Rescuing an overscheduled, overtested, underestimated generation, abeles 2015 highlights this sentiment.
The cons of standardized testing in past decades, tests were given to students to decide their placement in classes or to determine which students needed to be placed in resources class. Racial justice and standardized educational testing young people of color, particularly those from lowincome families, have suffered the most as the explosion of highstakes standardized testing in u. In the following article, some of the positive and negative factors are discussed. The pressure to do well on standardized tests can often put students over the edge, causing mental breakdowns and feelings of negativity.
Standardized tests discriminate against minority and lower income students college admissions, 2015 standardized tests discriminate against minority and lower income students joseph soares is a sociology professor at wake forest university. To find books and articles on this topic, click below to access one search. Highstakes testing is not a new phenomenon in education. Standardized tests are designed to have consistent questions, administration procedures, and scoring procedures. If we can focus less on taking the test and more on teaching every student in an individualized way as much as possible, we will be able to see. Standardized testing is a cornerstone for the educational system. This kind of testing was originally created to measure students performance and progress in school standardized tests procon.
Other possibilities include encouraging politicians to optin by publicly taking the exams, holding community film screenings on testing, refusing to teach to the tests, and using social justice pedagogy in the classroom to help students think critically about the ugly origins and abuse of standardized testing. How standardized tests shape and limitstudent learning. Opponents say this practice lacks creativity and can hinder a students overall learning potential. These tests are often the main factor in acceptance into colleges and universities, used in grade advancement for younger ages, and an overall indicator of a. Standardized tests are those where all students answer the same. Examining the pros and cons of standardized testing. Standardized tests narrow the entire curriculum in many schools, often squeezing out subjects such as music, art, foreign languages, and, especially in elementary grades, social studies, because they are not included in tests. A standardized test differs from other types in its purpose and design. When whitby students are assessed through standardized testing, we gain a valuable metric we can use to check the quality of our curriculum. Many other stakeholders have voiced their concerns about the impact of standardized tests and have taken action. Finally, we offer a critique of high stakes testing reforms in light of concerns about equality of educational. There are pros and cons to the use of standardized tests. The pros and cons of standardized testing standardized testing has become the arbiter of social mobility, yet there is more regulation of the food we feed our pets that of the tests we give our kids. American and japanese education comparative analysis of.
These institutions are under the perception that using the same exam questions across all student groups allows for a fair, unbiased approach in. Once the testing is over, it seems there is no reason to continue with the school year. Free cons of standardized testing essay exampleessays. For ela teachers, these tests also lead to subjectspecific narrowing. Standardized testing is typically defined as the nationwide testing that takes place in order to rank students according to the same standard. I am not sure when my first encounter with these tests were, but no student can forget the anxiety they feel right. Pdf the benefits of regular standardized assessment in childhood. Research institute mepri to conduct an audit of standardized testing in a random. Standardized testing is used as a method of comparison among upperclassmen across the nation to assess the individual, school, district, state, and nationally. Standardized testing causes many teachers to teach to the tests, meaning they only spend instructional time on material that will appear on the test.
Standardized testing and stress much discussion has centered on whether students are spending an excessive amount of time on standardized testing as well as on the effects of overtesting on students. Pdf this article explores the use of standardized tests to hold schools. Without these tests, policy makers would have to depend on tests that are scored by individual teachers and schools that have a vested interest in producing favorable results. No student should be held back, denied a diploma or placed in an academic track based on a test score. Among the world leaders in testing its students, the united states affection for standardized testing would. Misleading critics contend that scores on this type of testing can provide indicators that might mislead educators when it comes to evaluating students, given that the questions are limited and do not cover extensive topics. Standardized test results often connect to highstakes accountability for students, teachers, and schools linn, 2000. Many teachers commented on how standardized testing impacts their. Most people either think that it is the best way to assess students abilities or it is a stress. Being a student in the state of michigan, i have come in contact with these standardized tests. Their use skyrocketed after 2002s no child left behind act nclb mandated annual testing in all 50 states. Tests that measure as little and as poorly as multiplechoice exams cannot provide meaningful accountability. The net result is the net result is less wasted instructional time and a simplified way of timeline management.
Like many issues in public education, standardized testing can be a controversial topic among parents, teachers, and voters. Ive always wondered, what was the purpose of taking a mandated test. The disadvantages of standardized testing essay 1487 words. There are many pros and cons of standardized testing. Many people say standardized testing provides an accurate measurement of student performance and teacher effectiveness. Its difficult to favor any sort of testing, let alone ones that dont have a discernible benefit for you. Pros and consuse of standardized tests page 2 cheating by teachers and administrators on standardized tests is rare, and not a reason to stop testing americas children.
A fulltext pdf of this document may be downloaded free for personal, noncommercial use. While americans are busy constructing common standards and benchmarks, developing and using more standardized tests for all students, and moving toward standardsbased school reform, the japanese seem to. States and districts must end highstakes uses of standardized tests. Standardized tests have been a part of american education since the mid1800s. Do standardized tests accurately show students abilities. The pros and cons of standardized testing whitby school. Pros and cons of standardized testing tempus magazine. A 2011 usa today investigation of six states and washington dc.
Jun 22, 2017 the debate over standardized testing can be heated. With exams created and given by an independent organization, standardized test scores are useful because. Both sides are vocal about the pros and cons of standardized testing and the high stakes increasingly riding on the outcome. Standardized testing requires that students conform to existing standardized fields and frameworks. Students performance second, standardized testing is not an equal result of what each student can do. How standardized testing damages education updated july 2012. Disadvantage students get the shorter end of the stick when it comes to standardized testing. But lately, the common core curriculum and revamped tests are coming under fire. May 05, 2018 both sides are vocal about the pros and cons of standardized testing and the high stakes increasingly riding on the outcome. The testing culture and the persistence of high stakes.
Standardized testing is a subject that many people feel strongly about. The pros of standardized testing are very good arguments, but are not enough to overlook the cons. The term standardized tests is often heard along with highstakes. This is followed by a discussion of the nature of these tests and their uses in education. A brief look at some of the pros and cons of standardized testing. Independent researchers, and even the testing agencies themselves, all agree that high school grades. Sforsyth while standardized testing is stressful and time. Education could expand standardized testing into new fields art, music, literature, english composition, etc, understanding that each students unique makeup is worth specialized support, and encouraging each students particular. The big question is, are standardized tests actually helping or hurting student learning. The pros and cons of standardized testing show that the amount of information that these tests can generate is invaluable. Only two words, but a world of stress for teachers, students, and parents. Cons although standardized testing provides a relatively equal and fair testing method for most students, it has many negative impacts as well.
Today, standardized tests are used for arbitrating the success or failure of students, teachers, and schools. The following standardized policies are issued by the indiana state personnel department spd and apply to those state government agencies and employees identified in the scope of each policy statement which includes an overview of the states policy on these topics. Using test scores to reward and punish teachers and schools encourages them to cheat the system for their own gain. The main focuses being tested as a worldwide measure are science, mathematics and reading.
All standardized tests are so important in students lives, so why is standardized testing so unequal for students. The teachers and students are held accountable for teaching and learning, respectively. Standardized testing has been used to compare state, nation and school. The controversy lies in whether the objectivity of the tests is the best measurement, though many essential elements of what it means to hold the titles of student and teacher. Although one of the reasons this type of testing is being practiced is to give every student a chance to learn and compete with other students academically, there are schools that want to limit standardized testing. Jun 21, 2019 probably the greatest benefit of standardized testing is that educators and schools are responsible for teaching students what they are required to know for these standardized tests. The pros and cons of standardized testing affinity magazine. These tests affect the school systems, teachers, students, politicians and parents, whether that is in a positive or negative sense. Teachers can see what they need to teach and when they are able to teach it. Apr 28, 2016 a brief look at some of the pros and cons of standardized testing. Since being exposed to standardized testing, with the connecticut mastery test in 3rd grade. Is standardized testing ruining americas education system. Standardized testing and reporting star standardized testing and reporting star repository archive entry for the standardized testing and reporting star in the programs no longer administered by the california department of education cde section of the cde web site. Standardized testing in the united states started in the mid 1800s standardized tests procon.
Low scores can prevent a student from advancing to the next grade or lead to school closings and teacher dismissals while high scores factor into tenure decisions and continued federal funding. Which essentially is wasting time, where the student could be learning new. Pdf standardized testing and the promise of progress. Tests should be only a minor factor in staff evaluations. Standardized tests come in many forms, such as standardized. Standardized tests discriminate against minority and lower income students joseph soares is a sociology professor at wake forest university. I need books on the pros and cons of standardized testing. Instead of being accountable to parents, community, teachers and students, schools become accountable to an unregulated testing industry. The ultimate purpose of a standardized test is, as the name implies, standardization. Standardized testing frameworks in addition to designing to account for concerns of reliability, validity, and fairness, test publishers design a standardized test according to how its results will. Among the world leaders in testing its students, the united states affection for standardized testing would make a lot more sense if we actually knew if it worked. Their use is often touted because it allows students and teachers to be compared with one another, showing how well someone is performing or what educational gaps may need to be addressed.
1087 112 1425 495 673 1043 177 340 55 724 936 437 697 956 1251 176 244 728 198 253 1450 1093 1425 1206 1482 509 504 1306 735 1411 1362 1123 748 1138 810 1336 1208 525 630 1149